New urea fertiliser regulations are finally set to be finally implemented in the coming season, but there are still some grey areas that need clarifying.
“It’s a new stewardship programme to prevent future government legislation”
By Mike Abram
After a year’s delay the industry’s new stewardship programme governing the use of urea fertilisers is set to be implemented in 2024.
The programme is not legislation, stresses BASF business development manager Jared Bonner. “It’s a new stewardship programme to prevent future government legislation, so it’s not legislation as so much regulation and rules.”
The background to these requirements goes back to the government’s Clean Air Strategy policy put in place in 2019, which committed to reducing ammonia emissions by 16% (48,000t) by 2030 compared with a 2005 baseline.
Ammonia damages sensitive environments and contributes to particulate pollution in urban areas, with agriculture accounting for 87% (230,500t in 2021) of UK’s total ammonia emissions, with 16% derived from inorganic fertiliser applications, according to research conducted by Rothamsted Research.
“A significant part of that is from the volatilisation of ammonia into the atmosphere when urea fertilisers are applied,” Jared notes.
That led to a government consultation where originally three options were presented: to ban solid urea fertilisers outright; to limit the times of year when solid urea could be applied to land to between 15 January and 31 March; and to limit applications of solid urea to only being possible with the addition of a urease inhibitor.
After consultation with the wider industry including fertiliser manufacturers, port authorities and haulage companies, where the knock-on impacts on storage, haulage, competition and availability were considered, an option 4 was proposed by various stakeholders, such as AIC and NFU, and ultimately accepted by government.
Option 4, which only applies to English farmers, is a non-regulated approach and effectively combines the option to restrict the dates untreated urea can be used, and the requirement to treat urea with urease inhibitors outside of those dates.
It will be monitored as a new Red Tractor farm assurance standard (see panel), limited applications of uninhibited / unprotected fertiliser containing over 1% urea – both solid and liquid – to between 15 January and 31 March each year. Protected / inhibited solid and liquid urea fertilisers can be applied outside of these dates.
In total, the change is expected to reduce ammonia emissions by 11,000t/year. Government figures suggest the spreading of inorganic fertilisers contributed 36,200t/year of ammonia emissions in 2021.
There are some grey areas in the interpretation of the new regulations that need to be clarified before next January, Jared acknowledges. That includes the caveat that says unprotected / uninhibited liquid fertilisers containing urea can be applied after 1 April if agronomic justification is provided by a FACTS-qualified farmer or adviser.
“In practice, they are saying if it is a foliar liquid feed then there is a case for that to be applied without an inhibitor,” Jared suggests. The grey area is what the agronomic justification for leaving it out is.
“Currently what has been floated is that it should have the same environmental benefit from having it in, but it is a bit woolly and companies writing recommendations will need a good framework to use. Hopefully by the end of the year we get an explanation of what it means in practice.”
A second area requiring clarification is whether urea-based slow-release fertilisers with protected coatings can be applied outside of the closed period, Jared adds. “These are referred to as protected, which is creating confusion. But these don’t contain a urease inhibitor.”
Urease inhibitors help slow down the breakdown of urea into ammonia, Jared explains. “The plant needs ammonia because it can’t use urea. But we want that process to happen in the soil because when it happens on the surface there’s the potential for volatilisation.”
Volatilisation happens when, usually in dry conditions, the urea prill, which is hygroscopic, pulls in moisture creating a water halo around it. “What that water is doing is creating a pH spike, and it is that pH that causes ammonia gas to be formed and released [when the urea is broken down by the urease enzyme].
“So when farmers use urea there needs to be some moisture to get it into the soil, which can be tricky at some points of the year. What the urease inhibitor does is inhibit the urease enzyme, which gives time for the urea prill to get wetted down and taken into the soil.”
There are three recognised urease inhibitors available in the UK, all with very similar names: NBPT (N-(n-butyl) thiophosphoric triamide); NPPT (N-propyl thiophosphoric triamide); and 2-NPT (N-(2-nitrophenyl) phosphoric triamide.
There are several products available containing NBPT, which is now off-patent, while German manufactured 2-NPT is less commonly-found in the UK market. The third active, NPPT, is an in-house BASF product. Sold as Limus for solid urea fertilisers, and Limus Perform for liquid urea it contains both NBPT and NPPT.
“That’s important because urease enzymes are ubiquitous, and there are a lot of different enzymes that full under that umbrella,” Jared says. “So the NBPT and NPPT are slightly different sized molecules so they can inhibit a larger part of the urease enzyme population. In tests we see about 5% more efficacy compared with NBPT alone.”
In lab tests under various different soil types volatilisation can be reduced up to 98%, and on average 83%. “In the field, from 93 trials, the average reduction is 70% so obviously a few more environmental factors come in, and in some cases nearly a 100% reduction. It’s a consistently big reduction,” Jared stresses.
Obviously, there is an increased cost to adding an inhibitor to fertiliser. At the height of the fertiliser price increase, Limus was costing around £50/t extra. That’s dropped a bit to around £40/t premium with the generic NBPT products slightly cheaper. Limus protected urea is still on a per kilo N basis cheaper than ammonium nitrate, Jared adds. “So there is an upfront saving.”
As importantly, according to BASF trials, while usually you would expect ammonium nitrate to give a higher yield than using the equivalent unprotected urea, there is no yield penalty from using Limus protected urea, Jared says. “That’s because you’re not losing ammonia to volatilisation. You’re keeping it in the ground in the place where the plant can use it.”
In 13 winter wheat and winter barley Real Results trials, analysed by ADAS Agronomics across England, growers gained an extra £26.30/ha on average from using Limus protected urea rather than ammonium nitrate, he adds. Around £18/ha was saved through the lower cost of fertiliser, with a small yield increase pushing that to £26.30/ha (see chart in pdf).
Similarly, Limus protected solid urea gives a 5% yield advantage on average over unprotected urea in BASF trials, while Limus Perform added to liquid UAN gives about a 4% uplift. “That 4-5% is more than paying for the extra cost of Limus additions,” Jared concludes.
What are the new restrictions on application of urea fertilisers?
Fertiliser containing urea must only be applied where the following requirements are met:
- protected/inhibited fertilisers containing solid urea can be applied within any product use by/best before dates
- protected/inhibited fertilisers containing liquid urea can be applied with the prescribed rate of protector/inhibitor for the application, and within any product use by/best before dates
- in England, unprotected/uninhibited solid fertiliser containing urea can only be applied between 15 January and 31 March
- in England, unprotected/uninhibited liquid fertiliser containing urea can be applied between 15 January and 31 March
- in England, unprotected/uninhibited liquid fertiliser containing urea can be applied between 1 April and last application in autumn only if agronomic justification is provided by
- FACTS-qualified farm personnel or
- advice specific for the crop has been provided by a FACTS- Qualified Adviser and been followed
- in Northern Ireland, Scotland and Wales fertiliser containing urea (solid and liquid) can be applied as per relevant legislation
Source: DEFRA consultation response, March 2022
This article was taken from the latest issue of CPM. Read the article in full here.
For more articles like this, subscribe here.
Sign up for Crop Production Magazine’s FREE e-newsletter here.